Eventually, every leader has to hang something up—and that’s a good thing.

If you’re like me, you probably handle several responsibilities, and you’re always looking for a way to delegate and develop. But in the same sense, finding a person that can handle the tasks well can be a challenge that seems daunting.

Where we tend to make a mistake is trying to find someone much like ourselves:

  • Same style of communication.

  • Same line of thinking when solving problems.

  • Same approach to prioritizations.

  • Same humor.

  • Same values.

To some degree, seeking these similarities is legitimate when evaluating the next leader within your team, but your search needs to look at a different set of criteria. (It may actually yield similar traits to yours, but that’s a happy accident in the grand scheme of things 😅)

Here are five signs that God is already at work.

Sign #1: They Value Consistency Over Recognition

This is one of the first things I notice when someone starts to stand out on the team.

There’s a particular level of preparation already handled, and generally, I don’t have to worry that they’ll show up on time.

And when they arrive, they know their part to perform (not just musically—this goes for slides, sound, etc.). When something small comes up, it gets treated with the same level of care as something that’s “bigger.”

And on top of that, they don’t “toot their horn.” Sure, they welcome appreciation, but it’s not what drives them towards excellence.

Sign #2: They Pursue Humility Over Ego

If I give correction, and this particular person says, “Sounds good,” or, “Can we go over it again just so I have it?” then I know they are aligned in our vision, deference to leadership, and their part within the greater whole.

On the other hand, if responses are repeatedly defensive (this doesn’t have to verbal; body language, eye-rolling, and sighs of exasperation count), then that shows me a couple things. Either:

  • My delivery and expectations need work.

  • Or, this team member isn’t very coachable and cannot move past their own insecurities and comfort zones.

The latter point seems harsh, but it’s a reality that you’ll always face when leading a team. On a positive note, this can lead to mutual growth for you as a communicator and for them as a “follower,” but until they can follow with humility, then they’re not ready to lead. If anything, they’ll project their insecurities via demands onto other team members, creating a toxic environment.

Sign #3: They Fight for Unity Over Division

The last thing I need as a leader is a team member who:

  • Gossips.

  • Disrupts shared vision.

  • Brings complaints.

  • Undermines decisions that are different than what they would have made.

Instead, a potentially great leader handles conversations with care, discerning legitimate grievances from affronts to personal preference, bringing solutions to problems they’ve identified (or, even better, implementing those solutions and letting me know it’s been taken care of), and is able to set aside differences for the sake of moving forward together. When feedback is warranted, they handle conversations with professionalism, clarity, and an attitude that prioritizes the team and church as a whole.

Sign #4: They Take Initiative Over Excuses

When I see a team member wrapping cables, adjusting chairs, tidying up trash, or any other “chore,” it tells me:

  • They don’t need to be told what to do all the time.

  • They’re aware of needs that go beyond what’s immediately in front of them.

  • They know that responsibility and good stewardship sometimes requires going beyond duties lined out in a job description.

This is a big one for me, mainly because it gives me peace of mind that things are getting finished. In other words, I don’t have to babysit!

Sign #5: They Run After Devotion Over Position

Over time, you can begin to tell if someone is “phoning it in.” Beyond their skills growth, how they carry themselves tells much about the sincerity of what they profess, which for all team members is to be more like Christ and help others do the same.

I would even go as far to say that if they come up short on the first four traits, then they’re likely not developing this fifth trait very well, either.

That’s not to say that we should expect them to have it all figured out; there are definitely seasons characterized by burden, dryness, and doubt. But on the whole, you can observe the effects of their walk with the Lord evidenced by the spiritual fruit they display.

  • Are they loving?

  • Are they joyful?

  • Do they pursue peace?

  • Does their patience run thick or thin?

  • Are their words delivered with kindness?

  • Are their actions pointing towards pursuing goodness?

  • Are they faithful in their work, relationships, and responsibilities?

  • Do they show gentleness through compassion, care, and humility?

  • Can they maintain composure and dignity, not indulging in fantastic, self-absorbed outbursts at the expense of others?

In the end, most folks can tell when someone is there because they genuinely want to serve others, or if it’s just to “be on the worship team.”

So here’s the question: Who is showing these signs that God is developing them into your next leader?

When you see positive signs in a person, get in touch with them. Begin to invest in their work, skills, spiritual formation, and build overall camaraderie with them. Affirm what you’ve seen, and invite them into stronger, deeper growth as they are raised into who God has called them to be.

Be blessed 👊✌️

❝

Derek is the founder and director of Worship Strategies and is also Creative Ministries Director Faith Family Church in Fayette, MO. Outside of ministry, he is active as a musician and entrepreneur. He is married to his wife Kaitlynn, and they have two beautiful daughters.

Want Our Help with Your Worship Ministry?

A big part of what we do at WORSHIP STRATEGIES is to help churches improve how they worship.

Practically, this looks like discipleship, leadership coaching, music instruction, and production advising to help your team grow and excel in their giftings to glorify God and edify His people.

The cool thing? We do this free of financial obligation for each church. We have a growing team of folks who support us in our work for YOU 🫵 and be a blessing to churches who need help but lack tangible resources for improvement.

If you’re interested in working with us, then just click the button below to get started.